Sign Up Login
Icon

LOOKING FOR THE

Best Pizza in New York City - Upper Westside

Best days for Best Pizza in New York City - Upper Westside

Map My Location
Patsy's Pizzeria
61 W 74th St New York City, NY 10023
(212) 579-3000
Patsy's bakes their pies in a coal oven for a distinctive "old-style" taste that'll keep you coming back. Fresh ingredients and great sauce transports you straight to the old country. They've been making 'za in the city for a number of years and it shows. Bring your horse blinders though, because the scene (or lack thereof) and service can grate on you like a big hunk of fresh mozarella.
V & T Restaurant
1024 Amsterdam Ave New York City, NY
(212) 663-1708
Super casual with the requisite checkered tablecloths, it's a no frills classic with down-to-earth folks running the show. The prices will keep your pocket full which attracts more than its fair share of college kids. The thin crust doesn't do a great job of soaking up the grease, but that can be a good thing. We advise you to utilize your silverware. Don't get handy with the pizza. Depends on what you're into.
Daniello's
70 W 95th St New York City, NY 10025
212-961-0340
The star of this show is definitely the margarita pizza with its perfectly tossed and cooked thin crust and its oh so deelish sauce. The sauce has magic in it. We asked. You take the wheel from there and get it done the way you like it. We also like their options with the thicker crust, but they're not the crown jewel that the margarita is. You'll dig it, mark our words.
Vinnie's Pizza
285 Amsterdam Ave New York City, NY 10023
(212) 874-4382
NOTE: Our local Sneaky Sunday representative is working on developing original commentary to support this recommendation. It should be live very soon. Thank you for your patience and please enjoy this recommendation all the same.
Change Location